As of 12:44 a.m., Wednesday, with 17,615 ballots counted by the Eagle County Clerk and Recorder’s Office (final but unofficial results), Democrat Mark Udall won Eagle County 9,345 to 7,048 but overall lost his U.S. Senate seat to Republican Cory Gardner 49 to 45 percent.
In the race for governor, Eagle County voters gave the nod to incumbent Democrat John Hickenlooper (10,156 votes), with Republican challenger Bob Beauprez coming in a distant second with 6,400 votes, and by 7:30 a.m., Wednesday, the Denver Post called the election for Hickenlooper with a razor-thin 48 to 47 percent margin.
In the U.S. House of Representatives, incumbent Democrat Jared Polis easily won reelection in Congressional District 2, which includes the eastern half of Eagle County. In the western half of the county, incumbent Republican Scott Tipton cruised to the win. Both men claimed the majority of Eagle County voters.
In a closely watched state Senate race, Eagle County voters went with Democrat and former Vail Town Council member Kerry Donovan (9,999 votes) over Republican challenger and Orchard City (Delta County) Mayor Don Suppes (6,277) in Senate District 5, and overall Donovan had a slight 49-47 percent edge just before 3 a.m. (751-vote margin). Late returns from Pitkin County apparently put Donovan over the top after trailing much of the evening.
“A lot can change in 7 hours,” Suppes wrote on his Facebook page Wednesday morning. “It seems late returns from Pitkin County may have cost us the race. It appears we may have lost by 750 votes out of over 50,000 votes cast.”
Supporters were clamoring for a recount in comments on his post. Donovan also commented on the turnaround.
“Wow. What a night!” she said on her Facebook page. “It’s looking like my race is still too close to call and we still have thousands of ballots that are yet to be counted. Please stay tuned to my page to learn the results as the counties turn votes in. Every vote deserves to be counted, and I am thrilled at the incredible turnout in SD5!”
The SD5 race was part of an overall Democratic play to keep control of the state Senate, where their margin had shrunk to 18-17 after last year’s recall election. Whether or not Republicans take over still was up in the air as of Wednesday morning.
Democratic incumbent Diane Mitsch Bush decisively beat Republican challenger Chuck McConnell in the state House District 26 race, also claiming Eagle County by a margin of 8,440 votes to 7,049.
Democrats won both county commissioner seats, with Kathy Chancler-Henry (8,686) defeating Courtney Holm (7,571) and Jeanne McQueeney (8,337) beating Dick Mayne (7,892).
Republican sheriff’s candidate James Van Beek narrowly edged Democrat Daric Harvey 8,158 to 8,098, and Democratic incumbent coroner Kara Bettis beat out Republican challenger Sue Franciose 8,665 to 7,638.
In the nonpartisan Avon Town Council race, Megan Burch was the top vote-getter with 605, followed by Sarah Smith Hymes (565), Matt Gennett (544) and Scott Prince (471). The top four out of a crowded field of 10 won seats.
Got to the Eagle County website for more results.
Statewide, ballot issues did not fare well, with personhood (Amendment 67) going down for the third time; horse track casino gambling (Amendment 68) losing; and Proposition 105 (GMO labeling) also getting the thumbs down. Only Proposition 105 (public meetings for school district collective bargaining) passed.